Love’s insecurities got the best of her, and when she found out about Joe’s brief rendezvous with Natalie, she felt “wanted” by college kid Theo. Joe and Love may have been on the same team, but they were simply trying to make a failed marriage work. YOU (L to R) SHALITA GRANT as SHERRY CONRAD and TRAVIS VAN WINKLE as CARY CONRAD in episode 308 of YOU Cr. Love had it out for her, and the only reason she made it out of the Quinn-Goldberg household in one piece was because of her sweet daughter. Marienne also survived, but it was also touch-and-go for her. His only sin was falling in love with the wrong woman! Since he promised not to say a word, Joe drove him to a hospital and let the poor kid live. However, when Joe went to clean up her mess, he realized that Theo was still alive. He tried to convince her that he didn’t believe what they said about her, but she knocked him out and pushed him down the stairs. He found Sherry and Cary in the cage just as Love arrived at the bakery. Theo was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. And in true Sherry fashion, she and Cary ended up turning their story into a best-selling book. Eventually, she found a key and managed to get them out of the cage alive and well. It was touch-and-go-there for a bit as Cary accidentally shot and grazed Sherry’s ear, while she intentionally shot him in the leg. Unfortunately, Love’s jealousy issues took over, and when she accidentally blurted out that she killed Natalie for Joe, Sherry and Cary didn’t stand a chance. Sherry and Cary suggested that Love and Joe try to “hack their love life” by sleeping with them. Not many can live to tell that story, but influencer Sherry, her buff husband, Cary, and Theo, an impressionable college student with a terrible relationship with his father, Matthew, also Natalie’s husband, all did. To survive a brush with Love and Joe at their worst is, well, an incredible feat. YOU (L to R) MICHAELA MCMANUS as NATALIE ENGLER in episode 301 of YOU Cr. Joe’s only victim was Ryan Goodwin, Marienne’s narcissistic and druggie ex… but he kind of deserved it. While Gil technically killed himself after learning that his wife paid to get their delinquent son into university (looking at you, Lori Loughlin), Love and Joe used it as an opportunity to frame the poor guy for Natalie’s murder and made it seem like the result of a torrid love affair.
After killing Natalie, she bludgeoned anti-vaxxer Gil and locked him up in the glass cage that they rebuilt in the bakery’s basement (also Natalie’s final resting place). Surprisingly, most of the victims belonged to Love, whose impulsiveness did no one any favors. Anytime the residents of Madre Lina were in a strange setting with Love or Joe, you found yourself wondering: “when are they going to die?” While watching the season, there was no shortage of potential victims. Joe has a delusional obsession with finding “the one.” But, let’s be honest, if it wasn’t her, it would’ve been someone else. Their list of suspects this season included Natalia, who was the catalyst for all the disturbances in the town defined by tacky athleisure. Murder is the name of the game when it comes to Joe and Love. You can read the spoiler-free review here! 1. The murderous couple moved to Madre Linda for a fresh start, but despite Joe’s insistence that “everything would be different” this time around, they fell into old patterns fairly quickly and left a trail of bodies behind that would eventually lead to the demise of their fictitious happily ever after. Only this time, he was joined by his partner-in-crime, Love, and their new bundle of joy, baby Henry. On October 15, Netflix dropped the next installment of Joe Goldberg’s adventures. The wait for YOU Season 3 is finally over!